Free will is an oxymoron
How to be less judgmental
What is free will? We all have an idea that “we” can freely decide what to do in any moment. But there isn’t a little “we” inside our brains calling the shots. If that were the case we would have a “turtles all the way down” situation with little deciders sitting in the brains of the decider sitting in the brains of the decider and so on.
One way to get closer to what free will means is to do a self-experiment: Sit down with the intention to freely decide when to lift your finger and observe the decision process. Do it.
What you probably observed is that you had a vague intention and then all of a sudden your finger lifted. There wasn’t a conscious decision moment the same way that there isn’t a decision to form your next thought or idea. There was action and then later you rationalized that as a decision. We can also run this experiment in brain scanners and get the same result: We can predict in the scan what you will decide, seconds before you think you took the decision.
Should that be unsettling? I don’t think so.
How to be less judgmental
Accept determinism
I actually think determinism is a great thing. Determinism means: Your decisions and actions are based on your previous experience and values. What’s the alternative? If we couldn’t predict your decisions, that would mean they would be random. An act of chance. This doesn’t sound like free will to me; more like chaos.
You are your desires: Even in a deterministic world, your decisions are based on your previous experiences. They build your values, your beliefs, your desires. Acting according to those is acting freely. If you can’t act on them, e.g., because you are in prison, in a boring job, or lacking resources, you are less free.
Your desires are also deterministic: The obvious next concern is: Ok, I am free if I act according to my beliefs and desires, but those again are deterministic. That’s true, but that doesn’t change how you feel about them. If you had grown up in another country, you would have other values, other desires.
Accept it and enjoy the ride: While this can be unsettling, it can also be freeing. For me, it takes the pressure off somehow. I blame myself less for things that happened, and it empowers me to proactively guide the development of my beliefs and values. 80,000 hours has a great podcast about this.
Shape your inputs
Your beliefs and desires somehow brought you here and reading this will shape how you will make decisions in the future. You can be intentional about this and expose yourself to:
People: While the “you are the average of the closest five people” is false, the people you are close to have a causal influence on your behavior. Be mindful of whom you decide to hang out with.
Information: Echo chambers are a thing and they affect everybody. Use them to your advantage if you want to reinforce beliefs but consider a broader, more neutral media diet than what you’d consume by default.
Systems: If you accept that you’re just a product of your inputs, then setting up systems to keep you in check can feel freeing instead of constraining. Euzoia is a system like this: It’s a weekly reminder of best practices. Our post on behavior change has some more.
Understand others
If you are a product of your previous experiences shaping your beliefs and desires then so is everybody else. That mindset can open a window for compassion and understanding instead of instinctual judgment and anger.
Start with curiosity: Next time you catch yourself judging somebody, try to move to curiosity and try to understand what experiences led them to their belief. Maybe if you had lived through the same you would feel the same. An analogy that can help with this: If they had a brain tumor that led to this behavior, would that change your judgment? What makes that different from other things shaping their behavior?
Create boundaries: Determinism isn’t an excuse for crossing boundaries. The motivation for consequences is just different: Instead of “punishing” people for their decision, consequences are systems we create as societies to shape ourselves to act prosocially. We would still need a justice system, but one motivated by protection, not punishment.
Shape communities: How else could you contribute to shaping communities you are a part of? What could you do that would benefit everybody or would have a net-positive effect on how your communities develop?
This week’s challenge
Do the determinism test from the introduction if you haven’t done it yet.
Pick one thing how you could shape your or your community’s input.
Bet money on following through.
Useful? Help others find it with a comment, like, quote, or share.
Not useful? Share anonymous feedback. Thanks!

Discussion about this post